By Oliver Thomas, Staff Writer
Now that the Major League Baseball (MLB) season has ended with the Milwaukee Brewers winning their first World Series in franchise history, baseball enters a pivotal winter that will shape the future of the sport.
On Dec. 1, the MLB’s current collective bargaining agreement (CBA) is set to expire. This means the MLB Players Association (MLBPA) and the league’s owners will have to come to terms on a new labor agreement regarding a potential salary cap as well as various rules surrounding free agency, player benefits and revenue distribution.
The most pressing issue is the implementation of a salary cap proposed by the owners. With the MLB being the last of the major American professional sports leagues without a salary cap, league executives and owners have argued the sport has lost competitive balance. Their argument for a salary cap and floor is that large-market teams have a major advantage by outspending the rest of the league in free agency.
According to Morgan Sword, MLB’s Executive Vice President of Baseball Operations, a salary cap and floor would bring the bottom of the industry up in terms of what it is spending on players and bring the top of the industry down. This would give fans in all of our markets confidence that, if managed well, their team can be successful.
It seems highly unlikely that the players will agree to a salary cap due to it drastically reducing their earning potential. Many players have been vocal about their opposition to the salary cap, including Cincinnati Reds third baseman Sal Stewart.
“I think it’s bad for everyone — the teams, the players. I am not in favor,” Stewart stated.

A MLB salary cap is a contested topic between fans, players and teams in the sport.
On Nov. 3, the owners released their latest proposal, which would implement a salary cap of $258.2 million and a floor of $180.2 million for each team. The proposal would also delay the salary cap until 2028 to “allow for a smoother transition into cap and floor system,” according to MLB spokesperson Glen Caplin. The MLBPA is strongly opposed to the proposed cap as it would reduce player salaries across the league by approximately $500 million based on the current payrolls of each team.
The proposal also includes new player benefits, such as players hitting free agency earlier and an increase in minimum salary for players with two years of service time. In a response to the latest proposal, the MLBPA once again firmly stood against the potential implementation of a salary cap, despite the potential player benefits the owners looked to implement in hopes of getting the players to accept their new offer.
According to the MLBPA, the salary cap is nothing more than a way for owners to cut salary costs and increase their own profits.
Once the CBA officially expires the likely next step is owners locking the players out. A lockout would result in the offseason essentially coming to a halt, since teams would be prohibited from making major roster changes such as free-agent signings or trades, while also not being allowed to communicate with any players, including ones on their own roster.
There have been two work stoppages in recent history. The first was in 2021 and lasted until March 10, 2022, only resulting in a slightly later start to the season. In a much more consequential case in 1994, the players went on strike in the middle of the season on Aug. 12 due to the owners pushing for a salary cap.
This resulted in the season being cut short, with no World Series Champion being crowned. It took until April 1995 for the owners and Players Association to come to an agreement.
For now, fans will just have to see who blinks first. The fear is that this potential work stoppage will look like 1994. With the stoppage possibly bleeding into spring training and the regular season, this may result in either a shortened season or, worst-case scenario, a season without baseball at all.

