SATIRE
By Joe Reardon, Staff Writer
Thanksgiving is a time to reflect on what we’re grateful for, spend time with loved ones and, if you’re Xavier University President Colleen Hanycz, you avoid taking a position on anything.
Unfortunately, this year’s Cafsgiving has become a battleground in the culture war, with radical leftists apparently determined to politicize even the most sacred of American traditions: Thanksgiving dinner.
The signs of the revolution were everywhere. The turkey had been joined by tofurkey. Mashed potatoes had given way to mashed cauliflower. A bowl of mixed nuts sat conspicuously at the center of the table, presumably representing the diversity of the Xavier community. Even the gravy had an equal counterpart: Gender-Fluid.
Hanycz, visibly disturbed by the developments, was quick to remind students that the university remains committed to institutional neutrality.
“We recognize that Thanksgiving can mean different things to different people,” she explained. “As a university, it is not our place to endorse one particular interpretation of the holiday, nor should we use our institutional platform to advance a particular political or ideological position.”
The president’s commitment to neutrality was soon put to the test when a student pointed out that the holiday commemorates a history of colonial violence against Indigenous peoples. Another asked why the university was celebrating a holiday rooted in a historical narrative that conveniently leaves out the people who were displaced.
Hanycz listened carefully before offering a response.
“While we acknowledge that these are important and deeply personal questions, Xavier University must remain neutral on matters of historical interpretation.”
The president then proceeded to the buffet, where she encountered another controversy: the tofurkey.

Don’t even think of trying the turkey in the Caf, you will be disappointed at the bland tofu taste. But, this is what the liberals want!
A group of students had organized a small demonstration after learning that the dining hall would still be serving traditional turkey alongside its plant-based alternatives. They argued that the university should not celebrate a holiday centered on gratitude while continuing to participate in the exploitation and murder of animals.
Hanycz declined to intervene.
“Whether students choose to support turkey slaughter or eat tofu is a personal decision,” she said. “The university should not be in the business of imposing its values on the community.”
Across the dining hall, another student began discussing immigration enforcement. With Thanksgiving’s emphasis on family, the student questioned how the university could celebrate togetherness while remaining silent about immigration raids, family separations and the detention of people seeking a better life in the United States.
Hanycz reportedly approached the table.
“We recognize that immigration is a complex and politically sensitive issue,” she said. “Members of our community hold a variety of perspectives, and it would be inappropriate for the university to endorse one particular position.”
The student asked whether the university had anything to say about families being separated.
Hanycz paused.
“Certainly. But we must be careful not to take a stance.”
She then returned to the buffet.
And perhaps that is what makes this year’s Cafsgiving so remarkable. Despite the tofurkey, the gender-fluid gravy, the Indigenous land acknowledgments and the increasingly hostile political environment, one Xavier tradition remains remarkably untouched: the university’s ability to remain neutral.
After all, there are two sides to every issue. There are those who suffer from injustice and those who benefit from it. Those demanding accountability and those demanding civility. Those asking the university to live up to its stated values and those insisting that doing so would be an inappropriate use of its platform. And Colleen M. Hanycz, as always, has chosen her side. She just calls it neutrality.
Happy Thanksgiving, Xavier.

